IP Cameras over Coaxial Cable: EoC Solutions and Their Limits

How EoC works when carrying IP cameras over coax; distance, bandwidth and PoE limits, on-site line testing order, typical faults and when to run new cable.
Technical summary
Technology
Ethernet over Coax (EoC), RG59, RG6, PoE, IP cameras
Topic
Reusing existing coaxial lines for IP cameras
Level
Intermediate
Prerequisites
  • An inventory of coaxial lines and route information
  • Basic PoE and Ethernet knowledge
  • Experience measuring with a multimeter
In this article7 sections

In most buildings, coaxial lines left over from analog camera systems are still in ceilings, shafts and on façades. At points where running new UTP or fiber is expensive, slow or physically impossible, these lines can carry IP cameras with Ethernet over Coax (EoC) adapters. They can; but not every line will. Below we explain how EoC works, its distance, bandwidth and PoE limits, how an existing line is tested on site and when new cable is the better decision.

How EoC works

An EoC system consists of adapters fitted at both ends of the line. The unit on the switch side (transmitter, main unit or “master”, depending on the manufacturer) takes Ethernet frames and transmits them with a modulation the coax can carry; the unit on the camera side converts the signal back to Ethernet and feeds it to the camera from its RJ45 port. The camera and recording system don’t see the coax in between: the camera gets an address like a normal IP device, is discovered via ONVIF and recorded.

Modulation varies by manufacturer. Some products are based on standards developed for in-home coaxial networks (e.g. the G.hn or HomePNA family), others use a proprietary method. The practical consequence on site is clear: EoC adapters from different manufacturers usually don’t work with each other. Both ends of the line are chosen from the same product family, and spare units are kept of the same model. A faulty end can’t be replaced with another brand.

Distance, bandwidth and carrying PoE

The relationship between distance and speed

With EoC, the achievable data rate drops as distance increases. Datasheets usually give several values, high speed at short distance and low speed at long distance, and these values assume RG59 or RG6 cable in good condition. The real value on site is determined by cable quality, connectors and splices. In planning, look not at the longest distance value on the datasheet but at the speed corresponding to the real line length on site. The catalog value is a lab value.

Calculating bandwidth needs correctly

A single camera’s need is the sum of the recording stream and, if present, the second stream (substream for live viewing or analytics). Example calculation: if a 4 MP, 15 fps main stream with H.265 is set to 4 Mbps and the substream to 0.5 Mbps, about 4.5 Mbps is needed per camera. If the scene has a lot of motion or VBR peaks are high, this value rises; night noise also pushes bitrate up. Leave comfortable headroom on the line. For the logic of stream bitrate, see the CBR, VBR and smart codec bitrate settings article.

Carrying PoE over coax

Many EoC kits power the switch-side unit with PoE or an external adapter, send DC power over the coax, and run the camera-side unit and the camera with a PoE output. There are three limits here:

  • Power budget: The PoE power the camera-side unit can supply is limited by the manufacturer. Outdoor cameras with heaters, cameras with IR illuminators or PTZ cameras can exceed this limit; if the camera reboots when the heater kicks in on a winter night, this is the first suspect.
  • Non-standard delivery: Power delivery over coax isn’t the twisted-pair channel defined by IEEE 802.3 PoE standards; the PoE output on the camera side is the adapter’s own implementation. The IEEE 802.3 working group can be referenced for PoE classes and power levels, but behavior on the line is assessed against the manufacturer’s datasheet.
  • Cable resistance: The coax’s center conductor and braid form a DC loop. As loop resistance rises, voltage drop and loss increase.

Example calculation: the center conductor resistance of all-copper RG59 cable with an approximately 20 AWG center conductor is about 33 Ω/km. On a 250 m line, the center conductor alone comes to about 8 Ω; adding the braid resistance, loop resistance can reach around 10 Ω. If 0.5 A flows through the line, with P = I² × R about 2.5 W turns into heat in the cable and the voltage drops by around 5 V. If the same line has a copper-clad steel (CCS) center conductor, resistance rises several times and carrying PoE can become practically impossible. CCS conductors are common in RG59 and RG6 cables run for CATV. The fact that it caused no trouble with analog proves nothing.

Suitability testing of an existing coaxial line

Whether a line is suitable for EoC isn’t decided by the fact that it carries analog video today. An analog signal can tolerate a poor cable; high-frequency EoC modulation may not. The test order we follow on site:

  1. Visual check: oxidation on BNC connectors, loose crimping, barrel joints between two connectors, crushed or sharply bent sections.
  2. Conductor type: check the center conductor at the cable end with a magnet or by color. A steel core sticks to a magnet; in that case, the PoE assessment is redone from the start.
  3. DC resistance measurement: short the center conductor and braid at the far end and measure loop resistance with a multimeter. Compare the measured value with the value expected from the cable length; a markedly higher value is a sign of a bad splice or a steel conductor.
  4. Length and discontinuities: if a cable tester with TDR is available, line length and splice points are identified.
  5. Live test: fit the EoC pair, read the link speed reported by the adapter (LED or management interface, depending on the model) and record the camera at the planned bitrate for a few hours. Check the recording platform for frame loss and connection drops. A five-minute test isn’t a test.

Single and multi-port EoC topologies

The most common use is a point-to-point topology: a pair of adapters for each coaxial line. If many lines terminate at the center, rack-type multi-port EoC receivers with several coaxial inputs connected to the switch with a single uplink simplify the cabinet layout and centralize power.

Some product families also support point-to-multipoint setups where a single coaxial line is branched with splitters. In this setup, the line’s capacity is shared among all cameras on the branches; splitter losses and branch lengths affect link quality. If the cameras’ total bitrate approaches the line’s real capacity, revert to a point-to-point setup.

Topology When it fits Point to watch
Point-to-point Each camera has its own coax Each line is a separate point of failure
Multi-port central unit Many lines terminate in the cabinet The central unit is a single point of failure; UPS essential
Point-to-multipoint A single line, a few nearby cameras Shared capacity, splitter loss

EoC or new cable: a decision table

EoC is valuable when the obstacle to running new cable is real. If the obstacle is only habit, structured cabling brings fewer faults and easier maintenance in the long run. Every EoC unit is an extra point of failure.

Status Recommendation
Line sound, copper conductor, low to medium power camera EoC suitable
Line exceeds 100 m, UTP can’t be run EoC or fiber is assessed
CCS conductor, PoE needed EoC with local power, or new cable
PTZ, heated or high-power camera New UTP/fiber and suitable PoE
Historic building, leased space, no drilling permission EoC a strong candidate
Building renovation or ceiling being opened New cable; don’t miss the opportunity
Many splices on the line and an unclear route New cable

When deciding on new cable, category and topology choices are made together with PoE switch design; the PoE switch and camera network infrastructure page describes the scope of this design.

Installation and common faults

Points often skipped in EoC installation:

  • Verify that switch-side units and multi-port receivers are connected to the UPS. Even if the switch is on UPS, if the EoC unit is in a wall socket, cameras drop during a power cut.
  • Put a label on units with the line number and camera name; add the EoC unit’s model and serial number to the inventory.
  • Place camera-side units outdoors in a box with a suitable protection rating; don’t forget surge protection.
  • The link speed shown on the camera’s switch port doesn’t show the EoC line’s real speed. The port says 100 Mbps; the line may be carrying 20 Mbps. Track the line’s status from the adapter’s own indicator.
Symptom Likely cause First check
The camera drops out now and then Loose BNC, oxidation Re-terminate the connector
Image freezes, frame loss Insufficient line capacity Lower bitrate, test the line
Camera keeps rebooting Insufficient PoE power, voltage drop Camera power, loop resistance
Link never comes up Adapters from different manufacturers, broken line Model matching, continuity
Fault after rain Moisture getting into the connector Sealing of outdoor connectors and boxes

EoC is only one tool of the migration strategy; which zones are carried over EoC and which over new cable is decided within the overall plan. The full plan is in the analog CCTV to IP camera migration strategy article. At sites where EoC lines are permanent, add these points as a separate item to the periodic maintenance checklist; connector-related faults are caught early. To assess your existing coaxial infrastructure, take a look at our analog CCTV to IP camera migration service.

Frequently asked questions

Does running an IP camera over coax reduce image quality?

If the line capacity comfortably covers the camera’s bitrate, image quality doesn’t change; the camera stream is passed through as is. If capacity is insufficient, frame loss, freezing and connection drops occur; in that case bitrate is lowered or the line is improved.

Do EoC adapters from different brands work together?

Usually not. Manufacturers use different modulation methods; both ends of the line are chosen from the same product family, and spare units are kept of the same model.

Can PoE be supplied to a camera with EoC?

Many EoC kits carry DC power over the coax and provide a PoE output on the camera side. The power that can be supplied is limited by the manufacturer, and voltage drop increases as loop resistance rises; carrying PoE is often unsuitable on lines with copper-clad steel conductors.

How do I know whether an EoC line is suitable?

Visually check the connectors, determine the conductor type, measure loop resistance by shorting the far end, and fit the EoC pair and read the link speed reported by the adapter. Finally, record the camera at the planned bitrate for a few hours and check for frame loss.

Support

Contact us for support or a discovery session on this topic.

Contact form
[email protected]

Eretek Video Surveillance

IP cameras, recording and central management infrastructure. We plan blind spots, retention periods and the camera network around the risks of each site.

Knowledge Center

Other articles